there's no verdict, that i know of...

i can't even decide for myself:

commuter fixie: platforms with metal toe-clips and leather straps.
faster fixie: eggbeaters
townie fixie: bmx pedals (cuz that's what was in my parts bin)

of course, i sometimes carry a messenger bag and commute on the faster one, and i've been known to ride the commuter around town.

go figure.