Originally Posted by genny1
(Mallets seem to score best here, but still many strong reservations expressed for its use as a platform pedal with regular shoes).
...
If they are not a good solution, I'm thinking of sticking with platforms, buying clipless and switching out clipless and platform pedals as needed, or maybe buying clipless plus the Winwood Decksters.
Thanks much.
None of the clip/platform combos are intended to be ridden MTB style (with real obstacles etc...) without clips. The platform partially serves for extra contact points on the shoes as well as a way to easily get back on the pedals after a dab.
These pedals may be ridden "casual style" when you are riding your bike on paved surfaces without obstructions. The more agressive tread on the shoe ... the better.
The Atom Lab pedal actually has pins in it that will grab the sole of your shoe. One should be able to ride agressively on them without cleats. The question is ... do you really want to? You spent the money on the pedals and shoes ... why would you want to ride outside of the clip out on the trail???
Perhaps freeriders and downhillers would like the flexibility to ride normal shoes some days and clipless another based on the terrain. But XC riders will ALWAYS want to have their clips.