Originally Posted by DougG
I had pretty much decided on a Specialized Sequoia for casual pavement riding, but checking with another LBS that sells both Specialized and Giant, they claimed that they had not sold all that many Sequoias since the Giant OCR3 was pretty much equivalent and about $120 less. I took a ride on one that they had and it seemed to ride pretty smoothly. It doesn't have the suspension seat post of the Sequoia, but then again some claim that those are not the best idea on a road bike.
Does anyone have any opinions on this comparison? I had not considered the OCR3 before, but it might suit my needs. I'll have to go back and look over the specs again, but should probably get my mind made up by next week.
-- Doug
Giants make a good bike. Or at least the frame is superb. Problem I have found with the OffRoad Giants are the wheels. Admittedly a few years ago But the formula hubs are not that great- but then I am not a fan of any inhouse Hubs.
Having just bought a low end Giant, but not the OCR range, I am pleased with the riding of my "SCR" 3.0. Giant have always made a good frame- but so have Specialised. Drive chain will be the deciding factor on these bikes and you will have to expect to upgrade parts on both bikes as they wear out. Still can't decide- then go on weight of the bike. Still can't decide- go by colour.
Sorry I cannot offer any more advice than that as I am too new into road riding, but so far I am pleased with the Giant I have bought. Spec sheets may decide you but the final decision is down to a test ride. Both bikes for the price are good- Both manufacturers make a good bike and both have a good warranty system. Now If the OCR3 is that much cheaper- Why not look at the OCR2 if it on the same price ratio?