They seem nice, but I don't have anything to compare to as they're my first pair of clipless shoes. They feel snug. They work fine with ATACs, although I haven't taken them on a ride yet since I'm currently at my parents which is 40 miles away from town with dirt roads, so the only use they've had is rolling around/trackstanding in the living room. ha.

I'll post more details once I actually ride with them.