Now you know why I no longer use any wax based lubes; welcome to the club.

TriFlow is the original bicycle chain lube and it's still very good stuff. Another very good product is Finish Line Teflon Plus, similar to TriFlow...at least they both have teflon, other then that I don't really know, but they both work very well. If you have the TriFlow still around use it and don't worry about it; the more expensive stuff just makes your money slide out of your wallet faster.