I struggle w/ cold toes and also the underfoot where the clipless pedals connect. I wear out booties like crazy. I just purchased some Assos booties. Haven't tried them yet, but they have a good quality appearance to them and a wind barrier. We'll see how long they last.

I hate having to take them on and off my shoes especially in the morning when you are dressed w/ your warm gear on in the house You'd think I'd learn.

Anyone use neoprene booties?