Originally Posted by Haptown
But I think I'm going to have to get new larger toe clips. I bought Large size clips and they seem a bit small in the toe area for me - I wear 11.5 size shoe and my feet are on the wide side.
That might just solve your problem. I wear a size 12-12.5 (depending on brand of shoe) and recently put some extra large ALE toe-clips on my bike and they position my feet about as close to perfect as I could imagine.
And to the OP: I would follow the suggestion given above about the MKS pedals. I'm thinking about getting a pair to replace the ones that came on my Trek that just don't seem to be wide enough for me.