Originally Posted by Brillig
Especially true on ice. An SUV is at a severe disadvantage due to its weight when compared to a car when driving on ice.
On thick snow, they are generally better. On packed snow their handling is equal or worse than a front drive car, again due to their excess weight and momentum.
4WD and AWD only helps you get moving from a stop in those conditions.
What car vs. what SUV? I doubt a Caddy would handle better than an AWD SUV.
I have an SUV and had a FWD car. Trust me the SUV is better in the snow. My Subaru is great be it stopping or starting as long as you don't slam the brakes on. Having all wheels in gear is much better for slowing down and staying in control. Especialy in turns.