I would be more interested in knowing who writes the negative reviews. The positive reviews on MTBreview.com and other places outnumber the negative 10-1. I am not saying this saddle is for everyone but apparently it is for most people.

It is definitely for me. I have spent $130 on 2 of them in the last 6 months. I consider them my best bike related purchase yet. When i first put this saddle on my bike I only made it about a block before my blood pressure went up. It didn't go up because of the pedaling but because i thought i had just wasted $65. I thought man this thing feels horrible. What is up?

I only rode it a couple blocks because i had to go back to work. Later in the day i rode it over 10 miles and it wasn't long before the picture started to clear up. It's not so much what this saddle is as much as it is about what it isn't. After awhile you just totally forget it is there.

I don't care if mine ever gets broken in because frankly it is great out of the box. I have about 700 miles on one seat and 200 on the other. I can't really tell any difference between the two.

Sometimes I have noticed that my sitbones are sore after a ride. I think it might be from hitting hard bumps while the sit bones are on the rivets. However this is a minor soreness and I would much rather have a sore sit bone than anything else in this region of the body.