I've got an old version of the 3rd ones you posted. They are 5 years old now, on their second pair of laces, missing mucho material from the inside heal section (I've got some screwy heal bones, happens to all my shoes) and the velcro isn't very strong anymore. As far as durability goes I'd put them right up there with my Dr. Martens as the best shoes I've ever owned. Here's to another 5 hard years!