Originally Posted by Mo'Phat
For what it's worth, I don't think Wallbike will take back any saddle that's been broken in with anything other than an initial (or two) coats of Proofhide.
With that in mind, You probably want to go with a B17, either standard or women's specific, because the leather is more pliable right out of the box. Also, they're cheaper, so you don't feel like you are possibly throwing a huge sum at a miracle cure.
Last, keep in mind that it will make your bike look freddish, and every time you look at it, it won't look like the sleek machine you hope it will. (You don't think this is an issue, but it was for me...leading me to buy a Toupe. Bike looks hot, but my ass prefers my Brooks)
Maybe the Toupe will be perfectly comfortable on your new, properly sized bike?