Originally Posted by Daily Commute
The "commuter bikes" I tried did not feel comfortable. But I just have a preference for a more aggressive posture. I can see how some might enjoy a more upright position. The better commuter bikes also come with generator lights, easy shifting, fenders, a rack, etc., etc., etc. So you don't have to buy as much extra stuff. By contrast, my cyclo-cross bike didn't even come with pedals.
But if you like the feel of a road or mountain bike, I'd think twice before plunking down the cash for a "commuter" bike.
If you ride through 4 or more hills, it would be crazy to buy a three speed commuter bike. On the other hand, I've ridden with a commuter bike for the past three years on roads that were basically flat. I did not mind the flat handlebars and it's actually safter when riding alongside city traffic.
What I find wrong with these commuter bikes is the price. Unless you have a place to park them, there is no way you can leave a 1K Trek outside your office.