I'm having this same debate right now, but have basically narrowed it down to RELoad and Wig. There are some really clever ideas in the Wig bag, but I too, balk at the tapered shape. My thinking is that if you had something long and skinny though (bottle of beer, mini-pump, *****, etc.) you could kind of lay it along one side of the bag and then put stuff in on top of that (unless it's a fragile *****).