So, I've been using White Lightning chain lube since I started riding again roughly a year ago. It's time for a new bottle... but I remember resolving to buy Pro-Link the next time around - I just can't remember why!

What I'm looking for is an all-conditions lube that will set up dry and not attract too much dirt; I obviously lube more often in wet conditions, but I don't want to get into the whole different-lubes-for-different-days thing; I just want a lube I can apply regularly for riding year-round.

Which of the above is the better choice? Or do you recommend something altogether different? Remember, setting up dry is important to me, so if it's a pure oil-based lube, it probably won't meet my needs...

Thanks!

-chris