Originally Posted by socalrider
Wheels are the biggest issue with 200+ riders.. 36 holes are a must.. I would also look at cyclocross bikes.. Many of the new bikes come stock with 36 hole wheels, canti brakes give you a little more stopping power and most frames are a little beefier to handle the extra abuse.. Cross bikes usually come with wider rims to accomodate up to 700x40/45 tires, but also run fine on 700x28's..
I personally have a surly crosscheck, all steel frame and love the fact that I can ride roads or trails with it.. It is a very nice and fun ride...
disagree strongly on the weight/spoke count - 95kg riding 32hole
agree strongly on cyclocross - if it isn't a disc brake equipped cyclo-cross bike then...
disagree strongly on the braking - canti, caliper, rim brakes suck - get disc brakes
agree on the tire choices - more options with cyclo-cross bikes so you have a road/path/trail/off-road bike in one
disagree with steel - I went for beefy alumin
Ium because of rust issues in the UK