Pedals were bought new with the bike, so that may be it, and I can feel the click in my shoe. I didnt add any grease to the pedal out of the box, so maybe that is it. Cleats are out because it only does it on one bike, as is saddle because it gets worse when I am standing/pedaling. I will try switching pedals and see if that fixes it, if not I guess it's going into the shop.