FWIW I haven't ridden one, but the resounding response is that they're great. I know a guy who actually mountain bikes with one and swears by it. I would say get the premium one, too. You can get it at aebike for $150 without shifter.

As soon as I can I'm getting one myself for my commuting/kid towing in South Denver. I highly suggest seeking out an Alfine rapid fire shifter for it instead of the grip shifter.

I'm in the same boat as you, too...never liked derailleurs and I've ridden the best.

Hey, if you find a smoking deal on the Redband, even through an LBS, drop me a line and let me know where and I'll bring them my business, too.

BTW, you know where to find a nice 'cross geometry bike with quality parts for cheap?