Originally Posted by
McDave
Even though the chain looks to be clean and in good shape, it is possible that there is enough wear causing the chain to "stretch". If a 12" section of chain has stretched more than 1/16th", then undue wear can/will be occurring to your gears. For more info check out Sheldon's site...
http://sheldonbrown.com/chains.html#stretch
Good point McDave, I'm assuming dnpaha checked the chain for wear or the LBS did. If the wear is now out of spec then certainly the chain should be replaced. But I never replace an chain that's on an older bike just because its "old". The only other reason for replacing a chain would be excessive rust.