Originally Posted by
stevesurf
...and Chelsea Brewery...along the west side - I think we're up to about 15 pitchers there

At least!
Also Dinosaur BBQ up on 125thish off the west side bike path. Killed a few pitchers up there too
Surprisingly South Street Seaport for happy hour has some great specials and you can eat and drink on the pier with your bike next to you. There's a beer garden I think around the corner but that's a little more upscale - if it gets crowded it might be rough.