Old 10-24-07 | 12:23 AM
  #1  
BarracksSi's Avatar
BarracksSi
Bike ≠ Car ≠ Ped.
15 Anniversary
 
Joined: Jul 2007
Posts: 13,863
Likes: 6
From: Washington, DC

Bikes: Some bikes. Hell, they're all the same, ain't they?

Plucking -- my own little epiphany.. but with a twist

Yes, I know about plucking wheel spokes to check tension by musical pitch:
http://www.bikeforums.net/showthread.php?t=356361

And this is partially related to this thread:
http://www.bikeforums.net/showthread.php?t=356361

I was feeling that my Shimano-equipped road bike's shifting wasn't quite right, so I ignorantly started fiddling with the inline barrel adjusters.

Okay... "fiddling" is too kind of a term. I was spinning those suckers who-knows-how-much to see if I could get the derailleurs to move.

So, rather than taking the bike to the shop and pleading, "I broke my bike, can you make it work again?", I decided to finally figure it out myself. In lieu of a workstand, I hung it by the saddle off of my doorway pullup bar and start spinning the cranks & shifting the levers.

The derailleurs seemed to be aligned, and their travel stops seemed correct. That was easy.

However, I just couldn't get the danged chain to shift reliably from one cog to another. No matter which way I turned the RD barrel adjuster, the chain invented new ways of misshifting.

For some reason, I started looking at the cable, particularly the section that runs along the downtube.

While on the small cog, it was slack. I could tug it at least a whole inch. I figured that, even on the smallest cog, the cable should have at least some tension so that the RD would start shifting right away when the lever is moved.

I think it was partly because of where the bike was hanging -- the door frame & pullup bar probably resonate well enough -- but after finally dialing most of the slack out of the cable with the barrel adjuster (I really, really spun it before!), I could hear the cable make a pitch, about the range of an upper bass guitar string.

*Pluck pluck pluck* I went, raising the cable's pitch by a step or two. BINGO -- the shifter actually began working correctly!

It wasn't yet perfect, but man, it was better than before. Rather than just trying to count turns in the barrel adjuster, I started turning it while plucking the cable, making sure that I actually turned it just enough to change the pitch a bit, thereby changing the tension while shifted onto the smallest cog. It was like I was tuning the cable. Change the pitch another quarter-step or less, flick up & down through the gears, change the pitch again, test again.

Awesome. I un-broke my RD.

The FD's barrel adjuster had also been subjected to my ineptitude, so I started on the other side. I didn't even try test-shifting at first -- I just set it to the small chainring, then started turning the barrel adjuster while plucking its cable along the downtube.

After turning the barrel for a while, I started getting tension again, and the cable started making an audible pitch. Same thing as for the RD -- pluck, check the pitch, shift a few times, turn the barrel, pluck, etc.

Awesome. I un-broke my FD.

Just to be sure, I took it for a few laps around the block. Each click of the right lever once again changed one cog; three clicks, three cogs -- seven clicks, seven cogs. The front shifter was working well again, too. I could even use the mini-click to trim it and avoid rubbing the chain while in the small-small combination.

At last! Success! I can go to bed now... well, after I get the laundry from the dryer...

Last edited by BarracksSi; 10-24-07 at 08:00 AM.
BarracksSi is offline  
Reply