Originally Posted by Andrew Coggan

No need, I stumbled upon this thread today (which I apologize for dredging up again, but since you accused me of "adulterating" the impulse-response model and used other derogatory tersm, I figure that I'm allowed ).

Anyway, my only comment would be that, at least based on the graphs that you presented, you don't seem to understand how CTL and ATL are calculated. Specifically, they are not simple moving averages, as you have assumed/shown.