Go test ride them and see which feels the best to you. I voted for Fisher because that was what I chose. I like the geometry and the frame construction. The components where good for price I paid (Big Sur) I'm assuming your looking at the Tassajara since you asked about the Manitou Six fork. I think the Manitou is a much nicer fork then the Judy TT, and I also think the Tassajara is a great bike for the money. The shop I work at does a good buisness with the Tassajara's. But, if the geomtry doesn't feel right to you, then go with something else.