There is no universally comfortable saddle. Different butts, different riding positions, different tastes lead us towards different saddles. Some people get almost evangelical about Brooks. Personally, I tried to like one for a year but couldn't. I ride Max Flite Gels and a Regal. Check out www.Wallbike.com as they have a good return policy if you don't like your Brooks. Also check out www.selleanatomica.com for a what may be a more comfortable (if a bit more expensive) version of the Brooks. Good Luck and let us know what you end up with.