I would say go with the b17. It really is worth it. My sit bones are extra wide, and all other seats are either too narrow or expensive. Only complaint I have about the B17 is that I had to fiddle around with the angle and position for a bit until it felt right, but this is common with most if not all saddles. Unfortunately b17s go for around $69 because of inflation. But looking at how long these last and the comfort they provide, I'd say around $70 is a great deal. If you can, go to your LBS and see if they can let you test ride saddles for a decent amount of miles/time. Saddles are *****in' expensive these days.