For those of you who have been on the edge of your seat, I finally bought a bag !
Found a nice deal on a BA 15 encampment/dual core 2.5 pad.
Really like the slide-in pad feature.
Thanks to cyccommute for putting the encampment into the mix.
I was leaning toward the BA Hog Park, but the weight factor tipped the scales to the encampment.
As Staehpj1 said, it's a good compromise.