Man, you've got too much time on your hands. :-)

Honestly, I made a spreadsheet like that when I bought my last bike, and I had a second page comparing gear inches.

There's not a whole lot separating these bikes. You'd probably be OK with any of them. Go ride 'em and see which one you like. Don't let them oversell the "comfort" of the front suspension and suspension seat post. For commuting, it rarely comes into play except making the bike fell vaguely spongy (and I mean that in a bad way).