Thanks, man...geez, I never thought choosing fenders of all things would be so
harrowing... I'm going P45 all the way, by gum... But those Cascadias sure are pretty... ARRGGHH!!

Yeah, the guy at the LBS (who no longer works there) was somewhat nonplussed that I didn't want the mis-shipped P50s and was willing to wait AGAIN for the P45s... but I like them way better.
I just hope I don't become known by the same name that an acquaintance of mine was known by at the Harley dealership- "Details"