Thread: Amtrak...
View Single Post
Old 07-06-08 | 09:39 PM
  #48  
Galls
Junior Member
 
Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 105
Likes: 6
Originally Posted by BarracksSi
Oh, definitely, but it nearly doesn't exist in other parts of the country (such as my home state of Nebraska). Back there, even with the headquarters of Union Pacific in town, Amtrak was never taken seriously as a long distance option because of its unreliability and significant gaps in coverage.



Don't forget the rails-to-trails programs that gave us so many cross-country bike routes.

But yeah, I think that selling & converting rail routes is shortsighted, too. Rail travel could actually return to being a desirable option in the future, but they'll have to forge new routes to make it happen -- and might not even approach the amount of coverage that existed before.

For poops n' grins, I checked on a trip from Omaha, NE, to Devils Lake, ND (I looked for a South Dakota destination because we have family there, but there are none on Amtrak). Here's the rundown:

Omaha to Sacramento, CA: 43h 32m
Sacramento to Klamath Falls, OR: 8h 16m
Klamath Falls to Pasco, WA: 11h
Pasco to Devils Lake: 24h 35m

.... are you kidding me??

Driving:

579 miles, about 8 1/2 hours.

That's a little under twenty gallons of gas in my car, costing under a hundred bucks. It would cost me $700-800+ via Amtrak and half a week of travel -- assuming that there are no delays causing missed connections. Never mind that I can actually fit four people in my car and not use any more gas...
You are criticizing a route structure which everyone knows is horrible. Every train leading to Chicago is a fine example of poor intercity rail travel.

However, its existence in this form is the creation of political circumstances. It is not profitable so it relies on subsidies from the government. To get this money it needs congressional support, so the route structure as it is, many speculate, is merely retain these votes.

Something will happen, honestly something has to happen, without intercity rail this nation will collapse in future economic conditions.
Galls is offline  
Reply