I tend to avoid aluminum. I wanted something that was going to be tough, light and durable. Which is why I went with the Surly LHT. The difference between that and the Crosscheck are the chainstays. I am really impressed with the quality of Surly bikes. Yes, they are made in Tiawan, but I'd guess the Nashbar is made either there, or China. Someone posted pics of the Nashbar frame, and the welds were butt ugly. You can find the LHT online for 350-375. Yes, it's a bit more than the Nashbar touring, but I think your getting a better quality frameset to start with. If this bike is going to be a workhorse, don't skimp on something that could leave you stranded. I'm not thoroughly convinced the Nashbar touring is the way to go for a Touring bike.