The Thudbuster has definite utility for tandem stokers who's anticipation of potholes is stymied by the back and shoulders of the captain. Other than for cushioning major jolts, I can't see how the Thudbuster will address your problem. I think you need a proper seat for your butt and you might have it with the Terry or even the Brooks. Since you are a newbie you may need to learn to not rest all of your weight on the saddle and your butt may need some toughening. You might also need to learn to stand on the pedals when riding over rough pavement. Sometimes refining technique is better than buying another "solution".