Originally Posted by
catfour
Try
http://www.bikesuperhub.com/bikefit/. It compares your measurements to those of an average person, so you know how far off the norm you are. It also shows you how to set up a new bike to match your current favorite bike.
Thanks for that link, I hadn't seen that one before. Apparently I have some messed up thigh to inseam proportions which is why I think there's the conflict.
According to seat tube numbers I should be on most bikes 58-59... but by top tube it looks like a 56 or 57 would be a better fit.