I highly recommend the full coverage Hardcore Freddy fenders. I have had them on 4 bikes now, and have given them as gifts as well. They dont always mount effortlessly. But they are so worth it. About all that gets wet are your feet and I feel they are as wet as if you walked the distance you just rode. I have found the fender material very durable. I had to cut the fender to make it fit around a road bike fork, but they are not designed for that application and still worked well. Zip ties normally solve most problems with mounting.