I'm new to the forums but I have been MTBing for 4 years now, I'd have to recommend the Hardrock because my friend has a Hardrock(1999 or 2000) and it still gives my 2002 Norco Bushpilot a good run for it's money. And besides the Marzocchi would be better for downhill as I hear Judy's are crap forks. Hope this helps.