P.S. I have had that "ahhhhh, this feels so right feeling".
I had them put the bike on hold (with those exact measurements) while I tried out other bikes. Other bikes shops fit me slightly differently, and it didn't fit quite right. Unfortunately, after a couple of these I realized that the new fitting gave me more power, while the old fitting just matched the way I had been riding my bike for years. I could ride forever like that, but it didn't give me much power for hills or sprinting (pretty much all my "sprinting" is from intersections and stoplights, but it's still fun).
The bike I bought has the more powerful, but less "fits like a glove fit". Hmm.