Old 11-27-08 | 11:15 PM
  #62  
permanentjaun's Avatar
permanentjaun
Senior Member
 
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 1,713
Likes: 0
Originally Posted by Brian Ratliff
You have evidently never swam at the level that you bike or run. I don't get all this "swimming/running/biking" is easier than others. It's just what you are physically prepared and adapted to. All sports are as hard or easy as the amount of effort you put into it. That you think the swimming is easiest simply means that you didn't put much effort into it.

I swam competitively in high school. Swimming can be every bit as hard as running or cycling.

Also, another point coming from my former background of swimming: swimming is equal parts technique and fitness. What it does not share in common with running or cycling is that you cannot have the proper technique without the proper fitness. Since I've not been swimming for several years, I still retain the technique, but I cannot properly execute it for more than about 200 yards. I used to be doing over 7000 yards a day (broken up into interval sets, similar to what we do on our bikes), 4 days a week, in high school.

And lastly, many triathletes who excel at the bike part of the triathlon, eventually make there way into bike racing. They start by competing in TTs and then get into mass start racing. I've seen this progression with my own eyes a few times with the club I'm in. I have not seen many people going the other way. Cycling seems to be an obsession with cyclists. Triathletes seem to be obsessed with fitness in general; swimming, cycling, and running just being tools for the job.
I don't agree. I see the cycling portion as being the easiest section in a triathlon. Swimming to me is harder because when you stop swimming, you sink. You must constantly be tredding or swimming, and there is nothing out there to hold you up for some rest. Nothing like a swift kick in the head to unsettle your nerves too. The only consolation is that the swimming portion is generally the shortest in terms of how long it takes people to complete it.

The running portion is harder than the cycling because of the constant impacts with each step. This portion is certainly not as forgiving on the body as cycling. When you stop running you stop moving. When you stop cycing, you coast.

This is all just my opinion.
permanentjaun is offline  
Reply