First off, thanks for all the replies!

That's what I went with. I talked to severl guys at my LBS. The one that rides fixed the most likes Look, and had a bunch of reasons why they're better than eggbeaters or time, which they also sell. I rode them home from the shop then went for a grocery run. I haven't gotten in the habit of using my brake yet (winter bike has one, summer bike doesn't) so I did a few little skids and skips with them and everything felt solid. Clipping in is way different than my Look road pedals though! I felt like a noob trying to clip in while rolling.

Here's the new setup...