I got the Acorn bag I ordered today. While I must say the workmanship is excellent the materials are top notch, the leather straps are much heavier than the ones on my Carradice. I'm a bit disappointed, I thought it would be much larger than it is. I was hoping I could ditch the rack and bag I was using in conjunction with my Carradice zipped roll however I don't think it will be possible. I'll just have to see when I take a ride how much I can carry with it. I may end up ordering the larger bag although I don't like the way it attaches to the seat, the dowel inside like this bag has is better in my opinion. No knock on the bag itself it just appeared to be a good bit larger in the ad.