Old 12-20-08 | 01:58 PM
  #18  
snavebob's Avatar
snavebob
Senior Member
 
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 124
Likes: 0
From: St Louis

Bikes: Specialized Tricross SportCannondale Road Warrior 500, Trek 7300

Originally Posted by DnvrFox
I have seen folks at the gym, at one time as instructed by a "trainer," being told that they shouldn't have a heart rate higher than the FBZ, or they won't burn any fat.
I had been told the same thing. It seemed an odd statement, counter intuitive, and not what I have experienced.

Originally Posted by DnvrFox
And the machines are worse - those with the HRM built in - they have a large scale with "Fat Burning Zone" listed, as if you don't burn any fat if you are in the next zone, the "Cardio" zone.
I wonder if it is not a marketing gimmick? How many new fitness center users would return if they were told that they have to get the HR into the 80-85% zone. I am sure there are studies on both sides of the argument. Kind of like "global warming." Oops, sorry, going off-topic.

I guess so long as you do any exercise it is better than none.

And, for what it's worth, I have never been able to learn anything from someone who calls me "clueless" especially if they are not willing to back it up with proof.

I appreciate your OP. As one who struggles with extra lbs, it's helpful.
snavebob is offline  
Reply