Bengeboy you aren't by any chance talking about the Columbia Tower are you?

I would switch to the bike locker. I have had both just a locker and a full bike locker. I am really enjoying being able to keep everything on my bike (lights, seatbag, pump ect) instead of having to take it off every day. Also, you still have a place for your stuff in the locker so you are not losing anything just gaining more secure bike storage.