Well, I took the Peugeot for a 35 mile ride, and unfortunately, I liked it a lot. I was really hoping I wouldn't like it, and I could sell it for a good price. It seemed faster and more responsive than the Bottecchia, perhaps because it weighs about two pounds less.
I'll have to do some side-by-side comparisons. If the bikes are at all close, I'll sell the Peugeot.