Irrelevant debates aside, I'm going to chip in for the Time ATAC ROC pedals, the carbon variant of which I own and which have performed flawlessly for me this winter.
I wear these shoes, which look normal enough for me to wear everywhere:
I have the exact same shoes and use the Shimano PD-M324 pedal on my new Roubaix and plan on getting a set for my everyday commuter too which is a Trek 7100