Which is best? Really hard to say. From a quality standpoint you will not see a difference. Both very good quality bikes. You need to ride them and see which one feels the best. You need to see what shop treats you better and where you feel they will help you by answering all of your questions and making sure the bike properly fits you. That is what will make your experience a good one.
__________________
BMC Roadmachine
Kona Jake the Snake