Originally Posted by
DaveSSS
Colnagos are racing frames. Comparing them to comfort geometry frames doesn't make much sense to me.
No one is doing that, unless you think the Spec Tarmac or BMC Pro Machine are comfort frames. All we're doing is trying to find geometries that work for long-legged, short torso riders, without worrying about how marketers choose to classify those frames.
Your point about external headsets is very well taken, however; if the C-50 I cited above has an external headset, then yes, that will put the effective HT tube length right up there with the Specialized, Ridleys, BMCs, etc, making it a decent choice.
Which just serves to highlight how deceptive a simplified approach to geometry can be. We haven't even talked about different axle-to-crown heights in forks yet...