Nice area for a ride. The valets at the boathouse were famously clueless when I lived there a few years back (they're valets). I've never heard of a car being stolen downtown despite working downtown and living in the area for ten years or so.
Something has me thinking though: why would a dude try to steal a car when he's already got wheels? Not too many SUVs I know of that are downright jalopies. Not asking you to reveal a whole lot, but was your car a decent upgrade over this fellow's SUV? Then again, I don't know how the whole car boosting thing works. I hope your police report nails him.