Originally Posted by
AlanK
For a few months now I've been weighing my options for a second bike that will be used for utility (shopping, etc), inclement weather commuting, some rough roads/moderate trails and possibly touring. Since I already have a X-cross fair-weather commuter w 700c wheels I'd like to get a 26" hardtail mtb. I'm looking for a recreational hardtail because I want something with fairly relaxed geometry. I'd like to get something decently spec'd, preferably about LX level quality.
My personal first choice would be a decent touring bike which will also be a good all-purpose bike.
Another option would be to find a mountain bike from the late 1980s or early 1990s, without front or rear suspension. If you've got a good frame, you can build it up to what you want and it will serve you well. I used such a bike until it was finally stolen from me.
The problem comes because the mountain bikes today tend to have full suspension or at least front suspension. Riding with a suspension system is not a good idea for touring. The suspension will absorb some of the energy you're putting into pedaling and it will be something else that can go wrong. On very rough trails, a front suspension form might be okay, but even there I'd be hesitant. A suspension is also something else that can go wrong. On a tour, simple is good.
A cyclocross bike might also be an option, but only if you have the ability to mount a front and rear rack to the bike. Cyclocross bikes are set up to handle rough road and trail conditions.
I don't have any specific recommendations, simply because there are a lot of suitable bikes on the market. It depends on what you want.