Yeah, I saw that REI 15% off, too. Would be a good deal. Raleigh One Way looks sweet.

Out of your list, I would go with either the One Way or Sputnik. I was CLOSE to getting the Sputnik. It's a nice ride. But decided to build up a Steamroller. I like the frame better on the Sputnik than One Way, so I'd sway that way. Fuji is also nice, but more of a track frame and you'd have to mess with getting brakes. By that time, you're only $50 or so away from the prices of the Sputnik and One Way. Oh, also, you get a carbon fork with the Sputnik. Definitely worth it.

Also, I would definitely sit and ride on the bike first, which means staying LBS.