Originally Posted by
FLYcrash
I'll save the OP a theory vs. practice flame war and just answer you:
Nope, not a shred.

I like your honesty. All I have are (dubious) manufacturer's claims (as if they'd ever admit to downgrading something).
Anyone ever read about an independent test of chain strength? I used to have access to an Instron and it would have been a fun (though expensive) test to perform. I'd have to beg for that favor now though if someone was willing to donate chains to me, I'd try my hardest