I'm going to move this to General for you, get better replies.

I will say that I ride in NYC a lot and I found the glass rips apart Armadillos and Gatorskins like they were butter. And they're not cheap!

I went with the Vredestein Fortezza SE with the Slime liner. Once a week I pick out the glass that the liner stopped from the Gatorskin in front, see a few nicks in the back with the Vredesteins but that's it.

Double check what psi your rim can hold though - not all of them can take 160 psi.