Again, thanks for the replies.

I did entertain the bicyclesdirect offerings. They do seem to have some very good values, at least on “paper” (although hardly at the “discount” indicated by their MSRP). I have, however, firmly decided against buying a bike essentially sight unseen, no ability to test ride/fit, and limited service/mantaince/warrantee options.

This decision was reinforced by my experience at the LBSs. I began with a test ride of the Treks, did some more research and thought the Specialized Roubaix would be just what I was looking for. The Specialized ride was very nice, but when I tried the Cannondale I found it to be even more to my liking. LBSs have all been fair and competent. Two are especially good. The one that I am looking at purchasing from will order the Synapse Carbon 5, either 2009 or 2010 models in my preferred color for $1,999, and includes a full fitting and free lifetime “tune-ups”.

Did not intend to spark a compact/triple debate. I really tried hard to evaluate the pros and cons, the data, the opinions, and the “right for me” factor For me, the decision seems to come down rather firmly in favor to the triple. I don’t think that I could evaluate the issue more thoroughly without living with each for some time. In some respects I kind of wish it weren’t so, because it excludes the SRAM Rival set that really intrigues me, as well as the Jamis bikes, which are the only steel framed bikes I’ve found that seem like they might otherwise fit the bill. Still, I think that having drive train gearing that meets my needs is more important that the benefits that I might derive from those other options.

Anyone know of a quality steel frame bike, with a triple option, that is not a full-on tourer?