Originally Posted by
norcalhiker
etc
I'm leaning hard towards the On-One Inbred Frame, but I wonder if the chain stay is long enough for my heels to not hit my panniers.
This is the most important detail of all, is it not? You better find out. I suspect the stays are not long, as this bike is intended for singletrack mtb riding, not touring.
Crankset . . . a 94/58 BCD can offer you the super low and high gears. Rings from 20t to 50t. If you want flexibility, don't buy a 4 arm 104/whatever BCD crank . . . limited chainring choice. 94/58 and 110/74 are king here. I personally think tapered cranks are better long term than the revolving door OBB ones. The Sugino XD triple is a fine 110/74 if it fits you. 94/58 cranks are like the TA Carmina, Vega and Surly Mr. Whirly(these have interchangeable spiders) They cost more, but you get what you pay for.
my 2 cents